Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
Forum rules
Post in this section can be seen by guests and search engines.
Post in this section can be seen by guests and search engines.
-
MrMarried
- On the floor

- Posts: 1665
- Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2021 9:00 am
Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
I saw a post from a poster who said that her husband, before marriage, was serious about having a very regular sex life, and he wanted a wife would would provide him with regular sex. (Not her words, just mine from memory) and it sounded like the poster sought to live up to her end of the bargain.
My own understanding of I Corinthians 7 is that we are to be very diligent to meet our spouse's sexual needs. It seems like there are a lot of voices in society, including from the church, that argue against that.
I am writing from a male perspective. If I were single or widowed and wanted to marry, I might tell a woman I was interested in for marriage who was interested in me the following, after we would agree that we were talking in confidence:
- Tell her I was dating to find a wife and what was the reason I was going to talk to her frankly
- Read from I Corinthians 7 with her. Also Proverbs 5. Maybe the song of Solomon.
- Tell her that the reason I was choosing marriage over celibacy because I wanted to have regular sex.
- My expectations would be if there were no periods, agreements to sexual fast from both parties, no crises or health issues to be inside my wife maybe 10 to 30 minutes a day or have some other sexual interaction every 24 hours or so.
- Express my willingness to be totally available to her in the same way to fulfill her urges within the aforementioned parameters, also balancing priorities for earning a living, other family members, etc.
- Explain I'm getting older and not younger, so whatever I said were my current expectations and I couldn't guarantee what will happen to me physically as I age.
- Discuss children and express a willingness to try to have children, what lengths either of us are willing to go with a spouse to do so.
- Discuss other important topics, especially hot topics or controversial topics, interpretation about scriptures on submission, expectations for each spouse, how money would be handled in a marriage, care of each other's parents, and much discussion of how it would work if children were already involved, etc.
Theoretically, one might say if we aren't on the same page on this, let's go separate ways, not waste time dating, and let us each find a suitable partner. For example, if the other person wants sex once a month and I want it once a day, that might not be the best match.
One problem with this is I also think it is important as a man to be careful with a woman's heart. If I were single and got to the point where I felt like I knew a woman well enough to discuss such a thing with her, it might be heartbreaking to her or to me to break up.
I didn't think of all this as a single man, but I did tell the woman I married that I thought I would want sex every night, probably a few times. On one occasion, she said she could see how that could be nice. But she was a virgin and she didn't know what she'd want (another issue.) By the time I mentioned this to her, it felt like it was pretty much either her or nobody. I wanted to spend my life with her. I also perceived the Lord was at work in bringing us together, that she was the answer to my prayers for a wife, and I wasn't going to give her up.
So, from my own experience, I don't know if my hypothetical conversation really would work in real-world conversations. If I'd had this conversation with my wife, it probably would have been to get her to prepare her daily sex to take it seriously and to set expectations for the other issues. To be honest, I would have had to have left out the decision to split up if we weren't on the same page since I wasn't going to let her go.
I've talked about this topic with a couple of single men, one of whom is very actively looking for a wife, but haven't gone into this level of detail with the ultimatum idea.
What do you think about the idea of saying, "I'm looking for a wife who can have sex this often" or "I need a spouse who will provide sex as often as I need it, and I am willing to do the same" when discussing the issue dating? Women can plug 'husband' in there, too. Would virgins have a clue what they will be able to do?
If I were single and dating a woman, and she said something like this in a decent and respectful manner, my interest in marrying her would probably increase many times over.
My own understanding of I Corinthians 7 is that we are to be very diligent to meet our spouse's sexual needs. It seems like there are a lot of voices in society, including from the church, that argue against that.
I am writing from a male perspective. If I were single or widowed and wanted to marry, I might tell a woman I was interested in for marriage who was interested in me the following, after we would agree that we were talking in confidence:
- Tell her I was dating to find a wife and what was the reason I was going to talk to her frankly
- Read from I Corinthians 7 with her. Also Proverbs 5. Maybe the song of Solomon.
- Tell her that the reason I was choosing marriage over celibacy because I wanted to have regular sex.
- My expectations would be if there were no periods, agreements to sexual fast from both parties, no crises or health issues to be inside my wife maybe 10 to 30 minutes a day or have some other sexual interaction every 24 hours or so.
- Express my willingness to be totally available to her in the same way to fulfill her urges within the aforementioned parameters, also balancing priorities for earning a living, other family members, etc.
- Explain I'm getting older and not younger, so whatever I said were my current expectations and I couldn't guarantee what will happen to me physically as I age.
- Discuss children and express a willingness to try to have children, what lengths either of us are willing to go with a spouse to do so.
- Discuss other important topics, especially hot topics or controversial topics, interpretation about scriptures on submission, expectations for each spouse, how money would be handled in a marriage, care of each other's parents, and much discussion of how it would work if children were already involved, etc.
Theoretically, one might say if we aren't on the same page on this, let's go separate ways, not waste time dating, and let us each find a suitable partner. For example, if the other person wants sex once a month and I want it once a day, that might not be the best match.
One problem with this is I also think it is important as a man to be careful with a woman's heart. If I were single and got to the point where I felt like I knew a woman well enough to discuss such a thing with her, it might be heartbreaking to her or to me to break up.
I didn't think of all this as a single man, but I did tell the woman I married that I thought I would want sex every night, probably a few times. On one occasion, she said she could see how that could be nice. But she was a virgin and she didn't know what she'd want (another issue.) By the time I mentioned this to her, it felt like it was pretty much either her or nobody. I wanted to spend my life with her. I also perceived the Lord was at work in bringing us together, that she was the answer to my prayers for a wife, and I wasn't going to give her up.
So, from my own experience, I don't know if my hypothetical conversation really would work in real-world conversations. If I'd had this conversation with my wife, it probably would have been to get her to prepare her daily sex to take it seriously and to set expectations for the other issues. To be honest, I would have had to have left out the decision to split up if we weren't on the same page since I wasn't going to let her go.
I've talked about this topic with a couple of single men, one of whom is very actively looking for a wife, but haven't gone into this level of detail with the ultimatum idea.
What do you think about the idea of saying, "I'm looking for a wife who can have sex this often" or "I need a spouse who will provide sex as often as I need it, and I am willing to do the same" when discussing the issue dating? Women can plug 'husband' in there, too. Would virgins have a clue what they will be able to do?
If I were single and dating a woman, and she said something like this in a decent and respectful manner, my interest in marrying her would probably increase many times over.
-
Grapenut
- Single

- Posts: 16
- Joined: Sat Jul 10, 2021 3:14 am
Re: Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
We have a 26 year old son who is dating a wonderful young lady. We have told him we have no reservations about her if a proposal for marriage is issued. I think they should have a similar conversation but without the ULTIMATUMS. So many things can effect one’s sexual desire after marriage. This site is filled with examples - good and bad. So many unknowns experienced after marriage can derail those “best laid plans”.
It is good to be on the same page sexually before marriage and promise to love, honor, cherish, and negotiate the details for the next 50 years.
It is good to be on the same page sexually before marriage and promise to love, honor, cherish, and negotiate the details for the next 50 years.
-
MrMarried
- On the floor

- Posts: 1665
- Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2021 9:00 am
Re: Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
I couldn't have done an ultimatum. Even if one were willing to break up if the other weren't on the same page about this, phrasing it as an ultimatum might tempt the other party to not be honest or forthright. I suppose the ultimatum might be a way to get the other party to agree to a certain sex frequency after marriage, though. Is that a healthy thing? One might consider it manipulative. Or it could just be seen as agreeing to certain expectations before marriage.Grapenut wrote: ↑Mon Aug 07, 2023 6:07 am We have a 26 year old son who is dating a wonderful young lady. We have told him we have no reservations about her if a proposal for marriage is issued. I think they should have a similar conversation but without the ULTIMATUMS. So many things can effect one’s sexual desire after marriage. This site is filled with examples - good and bad. So many unknowns experienced after marriage can derail those “best laid plans”.
It is good to be on the same page sexually before marriage and promise to love, honor, cherish, and negotiate the details for the next 50 years.
If a dating couple really aren't on the same page on this-- one will have sex with the other on Valentine's day and their birthday, and the other wants it several times a week, it might be worth breaking up over.
-
IntimateMoment
- California King

- Posts: 852
- Joined: Sun Apr 02, 2023 5:24 am
- Location: United States
Re: Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
Interesting stuff. Of course almost everyone today has sex(even live together) before marriage and has at least some idea of each others desires.
Ultimatums tend to cause a break up more often than a capitulation. I do agree discussing sex is very important and some kind of satisfactory compromise to both should be agreed upon. And remember sex is only one part of marriage, good luck finding a partner if they have to agree, on children, money, religion, eating meat, sex and where to buy your morning coffee.
Then comes the fact that almost everyone changes their views a year or seven into marriage, hence all the divorces.
But in theory you have some good ideas.
Ultimatums tend to cause a break up more often than a capitulation. I do agree discussing sex is very important and some kind of satisfactory compromise to both should be agreed upon. And remember sex is only one part of marriage, good luck finding a partner if they have to agree, on children, money, religion, eating meat, sex and where to buy your morning coffee.
Then comes the fact that almost everyone changes their views a year or seven into marriage, hence all the divorces.
But in theory you have some good ideas.
Blessed to have a second chance. Say hi and share your knowledge.
-
DaveW
- King bed

- Posts: 327
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2022 7:23 am
- Location: Maryland
Re: Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
In first century Judea (where our Lord and all the apostle grew up) there were marriage contracts (called Ketubot) and in them the frequency of sex was spelled out, mostly based on the husband's vocation. Many exist today for reference. In the 1-200s those were combined into the Mishnah, tractate Ketubot 5:6. It states:
for men of independence, every day;
for laborers, twice a week;
for donkey-drivers, once a week;
for camel-drivers, once in thirty days;
for sailors, once in six months.
This was all written for the wife's benefit. There are court records extant from the first century that record many wives suing their husbands for breach of contract on this point. Some wanted the husbands to divorce them; others requested a court ordered change of profession to allow for more sex time. (like for sailors to become common laborers)
Edited to add: these wedding contracts were negotiated with both sets of parents (and often older siblings) involved when the couple was about 11 or 12 years old. The negotiations and subsequent signing was often followed by a day or 2 long drunken party. At that point the couple was betrothed (legally married but not consummated) and had to have a formal divorce to dissolve the relationship. This was the situation of Joseph and Mary.
Matthew 1:18
Now the birth of Jesus Christ was as follows: when His mother Mary had been betrothed to Joseph, before they came together she was found to be with child by the Holy Spirit.
for men of independence, every day;
for laborers, twice a week;
for donkey-drivers, once a week;
for camel-drivers, once in thirty days;
for sailors, once in six months.
This was all written for the wife's benefit. There are court records extant from the first century that record many wives suing their husbands for breach of contract on this point. Some wanted the husbands to divorce them; others requested a court ordered change of profession to allow for more sex time. (like for sailors to become common laborers)
Edited to add: these wedding contracts were negotiated with both sets of parents (and often older siblings) involved when the couple was about 11 or 12 years old. The negotiations and subsequent signing was often followed by a day or 2 long drunken party. At that point the couple was betrothed (legally married but not consummated) and had to have a formal divorce to dissolve the relationship. This was the situation of Joseph and Mary.
Matthew 1:18
Now the birth of Jesus Christ was as follows: when His mother Mary had been betrothed to Joseph, before they came together she was found to be with child by the Holy Spirit.
-
IntimateMoment
- California King

- Posts: 852
- Joined: Sun Apr 02, 2023 5:24 am
- Location: United States
Re: Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
Are you advocating that those of us that drive camels only get sex once a month? Glad I did not take that job.DaveW wrote: ↑Mon Aug 07, 2023 9:08 am In first century Judea (where our Lord and all the apostle grew up) there were marriage contracts (called Ketubot) and in them the frequency of sex was spelled out, mostly based on the husband's vocation. Many exist today for reference. In the 1-200s those were combined into the Mishnah, tractate Ketubot 5:6. It states:
for men of independence, every day;
for laborers, twice a week;
for donkey-drivers, once a week;
for camel-drivers, once in thirty days;
for sailors, once in six months.
This was all written for the wife's benefit. There are court records extant from the first century that record many wives suing their husbands for breach of contract on this point. Some wanted the husbands to divorce them; others requested a court ordered change of profession to allow for more sex time. (like for sailors to become common laborers)
Edited to add: these wedding contracts were negotiated with both sets of parents (and often older siblings) involved when the couple was about 11 or 12 years old. The negotiations and subsequent signing was often followed by a day or 2 long drunken party. At that point the couple was betrothed (legally married but not consummated) and had to have a formal divorce to dissolve the relationship. This was the situation of Joseph and Mary.
Matthew 1:18
Now the birth of Jesus Christ was as follows: when His mother Mary had been betrothed to Joseph, before they came together she was found to be with child by the Holy Spirit.
Blessed to have a second chance. Say hi and share your knowledge.
-
DaveW
- King bed

- Posts: 327
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2022 7:23 am
- Location: Maryland
Re: Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
You had that opportunity? LOL!IntimateMoment wrote: ↑Mon Aug 07, 2023 9:40 amAre you advocating that those of us that drive camels only get sex once a month? Glad I did not take that job.
Back then being a camel driver meant you were on long haul merchandise delivery that could take weeks on the round trip. IT was limited to require you to be back home at least once a month (rather than taking a 3-4 month journey into China or India).
Interesting to note that the popular trade routes had Jewish communities scattered along them, even well into western China. They still exist today. My good friend (former house mate) Barry Segal played a concert in western China and met many of the Sinim Jews there.
-
IntimateMoment
- California King

- Posts: 852
- Joined: Sun Apr 02, 2023 5:24 am
- Location: United States
Re: Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
Just another case of what made sense then is irreeavant to today. And why our gaining knowledge is so important to God.DaveW wrote: ↑Mon Aug 07, 2023 9:45 amYou had that opportunity? LOL!IntimateMoment wrote: ↑Mon Aug 07, 2023 9:40 amAre you advocating that those of us that drive camels only get sex once a month? Glad I did not take that job.
Back then being a camel driver meant you were on long haul merchandise delivery that could take weeks on the round trip. IT was limited to require you to be back home at least once a month (rather than taking a 3-4 month journey into China or India).
Interesting to note that the popular trade routes had Jewish communities scattered along them, even well into western China. They still exist today. My good friend (former house mate) Barry Segal played a concert in western China and met many of the Sinim Jews there.
Blessed to have a second chance. Say hi and share your knowledge.
-
Tantalum
- Under the stars

- Posts: 2344
- Joined: Sat Jan 09, 2021 9:00 am
Re: Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
Well, I’m sorry but for me this “shopping list of expectations” just sounds plain awful. Do you want a wife or a sex robot?MrMarried wrote: ↑Mon Aug 07, 2023 5:41 am I saw a post from a poster who said that her husband, before marriage, was serious about having a very regular sex life, and he wanted a wife would would provide him with […]
- Tell her I was dating to find a wife and what was the reason I was going to talk to her frankly
- Read from I Corinthians 7 with her. Also Proverbs 5. Maybe the song of Solomon.
- Tell her that the reason I was choosing marriage over celibacy because I wanted to have regular sex.
- My expectations would be if there were no periods, agreements to sexual fast from both parties, no crises or health issues to be inside my wife maybe 10 to 30 minutes a day or have some other sexual interaction every 24 hours or so.
I married my wife because I loved her. Yes of course I also desired her, very much so and of course I wanted to enjoy the privileges of married life. But to present her with a list of demands? An ultimatum? Piously justified with Biblical passages? Really?
There is nothing wrong with gently discussing the subject of sex while dating, being honest and trying to find out if you and your future wife are likely to have some problems in this area. (I must admit my wife and I sort of bypassed the whole thing to a large extent by not resisting our lust for each other and making love before we were married.) My wife told me, for example, that she had serious reservations about hormonal contraceptives and I was OK that. But ultimatums? Terms and conditions? Like some kind of business contract?
I must say this a list of demands like this would have been an absolute dealbreaker for me.
Last edited by Tantalum on Mon Aug 07, 2023 11:37 am, edited 2 times in total.
-
DaveW
- King bed

- Posts: 327
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2022 7:23 am
- Location: Maryland
Re: Premarital Sex Ultimatum for Post-Marital Sex
Indeed. Modern economies and distribution networks rule out all but the most physically tiring of labor in that list. So we all should be aiming at the "daily" side of things. * if she wants it that often.IntimateMoment wrote: ↑Mon Aug 07, 2023 11:08 am Just another case of what made sense then is irrelevant to today. And why our gaining knowledge is so important to God.
